Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Home/Towns/Fort Erie
Fort Erie, Ontario

Best pizza in Fort Erie, ON

From Garrison Road to the beach towns of Crystal Beach, Ridgeway and Stevensville, Fort Erie’s pizza runs from summer patio pies to family-run shops that have been feeding the town for years.

27Pizzerias ranked
8.6Top score
$15.84Average price
#1 in Fort Erie

The best pizza in Fort Erie

Dario's Family Cucina pizza review
#1 in Fort Erie
8.6SCORE

Dario's Family Cucina

Price $17.50Overall rank #33 of 261

The top-scoring pizza Joe has found in Fort Erie. Watch the full review and see why it beat the rest.

Watch the review
The Ranking

Every pizzeria in Fort Erie

Joe has ranked 27 pizzerias across Fort Erie, Ridgeway, Crystal Beach, Stevensville and Sherkston.

Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
Dario's Family CucinaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$17.50
8.6
02
San Vito's Italian Bistro & BarFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.56
8.6
03
Shaggy's Pizza & EatsFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$17.22
8.4
04
Rudders RestaurantFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$21.46
8.2
05
South Coast CookhouseFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$21.47
8.2
06
Da Vinci's Pizza and WingsFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$15.85
8.1
07
Vaticano Italian RestaurantFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$21.41
8.1
08
Papa's PizzaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$14.65
8.0
09
Aneta PizzeriaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$15.26
7.9
10
Bella PizzaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$16.81
7.9
11
The BarrelFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$18.25
7.9
12
The Sicilian ChefFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$16.95
7.9
13
Rina's PlaceFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$19.20
7.8
14
He's Not HereFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$20.34
7.3
15
Zia's PizzeriaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.84
7.3
16
Beach House RestaurantFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.00
7.2
17
Masi Central PizzeriaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.55
7.2
18
Flying J Travel CenterFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$19.20
6.9
19
The Plaice Bar & GrillFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$16.89
6.8
20
Domino'sFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$10.16
6.3
21
Avondale Food StoresFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$14.85
5.9
22
Pizza HutFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$9.05
5.9
23
Quality Pizza Burgers SubsFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$14.68
5.9
24
Old Bank BistroFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
—
5.7
25
Sneaker's Beach TavernFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.15
5.6
26
Pizza PizzaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$16.89
4.5
27
Little CaesarsFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$6.77
3.9

Nearby towns

Best pizza in St. Catharines80Best pizza in Niagara Falls75Best pizza in Welland31Best pizza in Niagara-on-the-Lake21Best pizza in Port Colborne17Best pizza in Thorold8

Short lists

Full Niagara rankings261Best under $1583Best of North Niagara109Best of South Niagara77
On Camera

Watch every Fort Erie review

All reviews
Dario's Family Cucina pizza review8.6
Ridgeway, Fort Erie, ON · #33 of 261

Dario's Family Cucina

$17.50 · Cheese pepperoni with cup and char
DirectionsYouTube
San Vito's Italian Bistro & Bar pizza review8.6
Crystal Beach, Fort Erie, ON · #39 of 261

San Vito's Italian Bistro & Bar

$13.56 · Wood oven cheese pepperoni with cup and char
990 Erie Rd, Crystal Beach, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Shaggy's Pizza & Eats pizza review8.4
Stevensville, Fort Erie, ON · #55 of 261

Shaggy's Pizza & Eats

$17.22 · Large cheese pepperoni with cup and char
3717 W Main St, Stevensville, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Rudders Restaurant pizza review8.2
Sherkston, Fort Erie, ON · #71 of 261

Rudders Restaurant

$21.46 · Cheese pepperoni with cup and char
250 Pleasant Beach Rd, Sherkston, ON
DirectionsYouTube
South Coast Cookhouse pizza review8.2
Crystal Beach, Fort Erie, ON · #73 of 261

South Coast Cookhouse

$21.47 · Large cheese pepperoni with cup and char
423 Derby Rd, Crystal Beach, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Da Vinci's Pizza and Wings pizza review8.1
Fort Erie, ON · #77 of 261

Da Vinci's Pizza and Wings

$15.85 · Large cheese pepperoni
1206 Dominion Rd, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Vaticano Italian Restaurant pizza review8.1
Fort Erie, ON · #86 of 261

Vaticano Italian Restaurant

$21.41 · Cheese and salami pizza (no pepperoni available)
90 Niagara Blvd, Fort Erie, ON L2A 3G3
DirectionsYouTube
Papa's Pizza pizza review8.0
Ridgeway, Fort Erie, ON · #89 of 261

Papa's Pizza

$14.65 · Large cheese pepperoni
328 Ridge Rd N, Ridgeway, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Aneta Pizzeria pizza review7.9
Ridgeway, Fort Erie, ON · #90 of 261

Aneta Pizzeria

$15.26 · Large cheese pepperoni
504 Ridge Rd N, Ridgeway, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Bella Pizza pizza review7.9
Ridgeway, Fort Erie, ON · #92 of 261

Bella Pizza

$16.81 · Large cheese pepperoni
3840 Dominion Rd, Ridgeway, ON
DirectionsYouTube
The Barrel pizza review7.9
Fort Erie, ON · #98 of 261

The Barrel

$18.25 · Large cheese pepperoni
224 Garrison Rd, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
The Sicilian Chef pizza review7.9
Fort Erie, ON · #101 of 261

The Sicilian Chef

$16.95 · Large 16-inch cheese pepperoni
68 Goderich St, Fort Erie, ON L2A 3S6
DirectionsYouTube
Rina's Place pizza review7.8
Fort Erie, ON · #109 of 261

Rina's Place

$19.20 · Large 16-inch cheese pepperoni
DirectionsYouTube
He's Not Here pizza review7.3
Fort Erie, ON · #144 of 261

He's Not Here

$20.34 · Large 14-inch cheese pepperoni
365 Niagara Blvd, Fort Erie, ON L2A 3H1
DirectionsYouTube
Zia's Pizzeria pizza review7.3
Fort Erie, ON · #151 of 261

Zia's Pizzeria

$13.84 · Large cheese pepperoni
1243 Garrison Rd, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Beach House Restaurant pizza review7.2
Crystal Beach, Fort Erie, ON · #152 of 261

Beach House Restaurant

$13.00 · Cheese pepperoni
4130 Erie Rd, Crystal Beach, ON L0S 1B0
DirectionsYouTube
Masi Central Pizzeria pizza review7.2
Fort Erie, ON · #156 of 261

Masi Central Pizzeria

$13.55 · Large thick crust cheese pepperoni
161 Central Ave, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Flying J Travel Center pizza review6.9
Fort Erie, ON · #175 of 261

Flying J Travel Center

$19.20 · Cheese pepperoni pizza
1637 Pettit Rd, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
The Plaice Bar & Grill pizza review6.8
Fort Erie, ON · #180 of 261

The Plaice Bar & Grill

$16.89 · Cheese pepperoni
981 Garrison Rd, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Domino's pizza review6.3
Ridgeway, Fort Erie, ON · #197 of 261

Domino's

$10.16 · Hand-tossed cheese pepperoni
3860 Dominion Rd, Ridgeway, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Avondale Food Stores pizza review5.9
Stevensville, Fort Erie, ON · #213 of 261

Avondale Food Stores

$14.85 · Cheese pepperoni, cut in quarters
3231 Snyder St, Stevensville, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Pizza Hut pizza review5.9
Fort Erie, ON · #217 of 261

Pizza Hut

$9.05 · Pepperoni flatbread pizza
450 Garrison Rd Unit 130, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Quality Pizza Burgers Subs pizza review5.9
Fort Erie, ON · #218 of 261

Quality Pizza Burgers Subs

$14.68 · Large 14-inch cheese pepperoni
336 Central Ave, Fort Erie, ON L2A 2L4
DirectionsYouTube
Old Bank Bistro pizza review5.7
Fort Erie, ON · #228 of 261

Old Bank Bistro

Cheese pepperoni with cup and char
41 Jarvis St, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Sneaker's Beach Tavern pizza review5.6
Crystal Beach, Fort Erie, ON · #231 of 261

Sneaker's Beach Tavern

$13.15 · Cheese pepperoni
4020 Erie Rd, Crystal Beach, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Pizza Pizza pizza review4.5
Fort Erie, ON · #244 of 261

Pizza Pizza

$16.89 · Medium cauliflower crust pepperoni
310 Garrison Rd, Fort Erie, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Little Caesars pizza review3.9
Fort Erie, ON · #254 of 261

Little Caesars

$6.77 · Hot-N-Ready cheese pepperoni
427 Garrison Rd, Fort Erie, ON L2A 1N1
DirectionsYouTube
335 on the Ridge pizza review—
Ridgeway, Fort Erie, ON

335 on the Ridge

$25.99 · Wood oven cheese pepperoni
335 Ridge Rd N, Ridgeway, ON
DirectionsYouTube

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria