Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings

Home/Rankings/Best Pizza in South Niagara

Joe’s Short List

Best of South Niagara

The best pizza in Welland, Port Colborne, Fort Erie and Pelham, down along the Lake Erie side of the region, ranked together.

77Pizzerias

9.1Top score

$16.27Average price

Rank

Pizzeria

Town

Price

Joe’s Score

01

Tailgates Bar & GrillWelland, ON

Welland

—

9.1

02

Luciano's PizzeriaWelland, ON

Welland

$19.15

8.9

03

The SpotPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$15.26

8.9

04

Angelina's PizzeriaWelland, ON

Welland

$15.54

8.8

05

Volcano PizzeriaWelland, ON

Welland

$13.50

8.8

06

Matteo's RistoranteWelland, ON

Welland

$19.21

8.7

07

The Lock Wood Fired PizzaPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$12.00

8.7

08

Antonio's PizzeriaWelland, ON

Welland

$16.95

8.6

09

Dario's Family CucinaFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$17.50

8.6

10

Mario's PlaceWelland, ON

Welland

$16.75

8.6

11

San Vito's Italian Bistro & BarFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$13.56

8.6

12

Super Mario'sPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

—

8.5

13

The Brick Oven Pizza CompanyWelland, ON

Welland

$13.00

8.5

14

Dough and DesignWelland, ON

Welland

$19.00

8.4

15

For Pizza's SakeWelland, ON

Welland

$29.37

8.4

16

Rose City PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

$20.30

8.4

17

Shaggy's Pizza & EatsFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$17.22

8.4

18

Welland Jackfish StadiumWelland, ON

Welland

$36.00

8.4

19

Whisky Run Golf ClubPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$22.54

8.4

20

Handlebar Hanks RoadhouseWelland, ON

Welland

$19.20

8.2

21

Rudders RestaurantFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$21.46

8.2

22

South Coast CookhouseFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$21.47

8.2

23

Breakwall Brewing CompanyPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$17.52

8.1

24

Da Vinci's Pizza and WingsFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$15.85

8.1

25

Vaticano Italian RestaurantFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$21.41

8.1

26

Cured Tapas & CocktailsPelham, ON

Pelham

$20.34

8.0

27

Papa's PizzaFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$14.65

8.0

28

Aneta PizzeriaFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$15.26

7.9

29

Bella PizzaFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$16.81

7.9

30

The BarrelFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$18.25

7.9

31

The Sicilian ChefFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$16.95

7.9

32

Reeb HousePort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$16.94

7.8

33

Rina's PlaceFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$19.20

7.8

34

The Rex HotelWelland, ON

Welland

$16.39

7.8

35

Merrittville Wood Fired PizzaPelham, ON

Pelham

—

7.7

36

Scotty's On KingWelland, ON

Welland

$23.75

7.4

37

Boston PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

—

7.3

38

He's Not HereFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$20.34

7.3

39

Owl PizzaPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$14.68

7.3

40

Zia's PizzeriaFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$13.84

7.3

41

Beach House RestaurantFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$13.00

7.2

42

Masi Central PizzeriaFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$13.55

7.2

43

Nino PizzaPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$12.40

7.2

44

Red Swan PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

$13.50

7.2

45

Wings BlockWelland, ON

Welland

$16.33

7.2

46

Mulberry'sPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$11.29

7.1

47

Storky'sPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$10.99

7.1

48

Vincent's PizzeriaWelland, ON

Welland

$17.50

7.1

49

Flying J Travel CenterFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$19.20

6.9

50

The Plaice Bar & GrillFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$16.89

6.8

51

Tito's Pizza and WingsPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$14.49

6.8

52

Ever Fresh PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

$13.55

6.7

53

Four Seasons BakeryWelland, ON

Welland

$30.00

6.7

54

The BelmontPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$14.97

6.4

55

The KavernWelland, ON

Welland

$16.94

6.4

56

Domino'sFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$10.16

6.3

57

City South PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

$13.84

6.2

58

Gino's PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

$13.56

6.2

59

Pizza HutPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$20.33

6.1

60

Pizza PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

$18.75

6.1

61

Twice The Deal PizzaWelland, ON

Welland

$10.16

6.1

62

Avondale Food StoresFort Erie, ON

5.9

5.9

Moe's Tap & WingsPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

—

5.9

65

Pizza HutFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$9.05

5.9

66

Quality Pizza Burgers SubsFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$14.68

5.9

67

Domino'sPort Colborne, ON

5.8

5.8

Old Bank BistroFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

—

5.7

70

Trappers Sports BarWelland, ON

Welland

—

5.7

71

Sneaker's Beach TavernFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$13.15

5.6

72

CC's Dugout Italian EateryWelland, ON

Welland

$5.00

5.5

73

Pizza PizzaFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$16.89

4.5

74

7-ElevenPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$10.50

4.2

75

Little CaesarsFort Erie, ON

Fort Erie

$6.77

3.9

76

Little CaesarsPort Colborne, ON

Port Colborne

$16.95

3.6

77

Little CaesarsWelland, ON

Welland

$14.68

2.5

On Camera

Watch the top picks

Welland, Port Colborne, Fort Erie and the rest of South Niagara, on camera.

9.1

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria