Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings

Home/Rankings

The Full Leaderboard

Every Niagara pizzeria Joe has ranked

261 pizzerias across 8 towns, sorted by Joe’s score. Filter by town, search by name, or sort by price to find the best pie near you.

9.3Top score

261Pizzerias ranked

$17.46Average price

8Towns

Rank

Pizzeria

Town

Price

Joe’s Score

Niagara Oast House BrewersNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

9.3

Antica Pizzeria & RistoranteNiagara Falls, ON

9.2

Pete's Pizza (Dorchester Rd)Niagara Falls, ON

9.2

The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports BarNiagara Falls, ON

9.2

oddBarSt. Catharines, ON

9.1

Boss PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

9.1

Di's Pizza PiesSt. Catharines, ON

9.1

Pie Guys PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON

9.1

Tailgates Bar & GrillWelland, ON

9.1

Volcano PizzeriaThorold, ON

9.1

Yank's Old Niagara Bar & GrillNiagara Falls, ON

9.1

BrocatoeatzSt. Catharines, ON

9.0

Frank's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON

9.0

Johnny Rocco's Italian GrillSt. Catharines, ON

9.0

Pie Guys Tap And GrillSt. Catharines, ON

9.0

Bricks & BarleyNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

8.9

Cafe AmoreSt. Catharines, ON

8.9

Carmine's Pizzeria ItalianoNiagara Falls, ON

8.9

CounterpieNiagara Falls, ON

8.9

Luciano's PizzeriaWelland, ON

8.9

Pete's Pizza (Bunting Rd)St. Catharines, ON

8.9

The PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON

8.9

The SpotPort Colborne, ON

8.9

Zappi's Pizza & PastaNiagara Falls, ON

8.9

Angelina's PizzeriaWelland, ON

8.8

Garage PizzaNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

8.8

Volcano PizzeriaWelland, ON

8.8

Fat Louie's American Style Pizzeria & BarSt. Catharines, ON

8.7

Grand Central SportsNiagara Falls, ON

8.7

Matteo's RistoranteWelland, ON

8.7

The Lock Wood Fired PizzaPort Colborne, ON

8.7

Antonio's PizzeriaWelland, ON

8.6

Dario's Family CucinaFort Erie, ON

8.6

Golden GrillSt. Catharines, ON

8.6

Johnny Rocco's Pizza WagonThorold, ON

8.6

Mario's PlaceWelland, ON

8.6

Olee's Ale HouseSt. Catharines, ON

8.6

Sal's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON

8.6

San Vito's Italian Bistro & BarFort Erie, ON

8.6

The Twisted PigSt. Catharines, ON

8.6

Fat Louie's Pizzeria & BarSt. Catharines, ON

8.5

Pete's Pizza (Lakeshore Rd)St. Catharines, ON

8.5

Stirling Niagara Pub & EateryNiagara Falls, ON

8.5

Super Mario'sPort Colborne, ON

8.5

The Brick Oven Pizza CompanyWelland, ON

8.5

Dough and DesignWelland, ON

8.4

For Pizza's SakeWelland, ON

8.4

Johnny Rocco's Italian GrillNiagara Falls, ON

8.4

Napoli Ristorante PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON

8.4

Petrullo MarketplaceNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

8.4

Pie Guys Pizzeria (Linwell Rd)St. Catharines, ON

8.4

Restaurant 88St. Catharines, ON

8.4

Rollin' PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

8.4

Rose City PizzaWelland, ON

8.4

Shaggy's Pizza & EatsFort Erie, ON

8.4

Welland Jackfish StadiumWelland, ON

8.4

Whisky Run Golf ClubPort Colborne, ON

8.4

13th Street WinerySt. Catharines, ON

8.3

Big Marco's Italian RestaurantSt. Catharines, ON

8.3

Fabio's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

8.3

Kully's Original Sports BarSt. Catharines, ON

8.3

Pieza Pizza & VinoNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

8.3

Pizza FormaggioNiagara Falls, ON

8.3

Queen's Guard PubNiagara Falls, ON

8.3

Ravine Vineyard Estate WineryNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

8.3

Carson's PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON

8.2

ComparùNiagara Falls, ON

8.2

Dairy QueenNiagara Falls, ON

8.2

Handlebar Hanks RoadhouseWelland, ON

8.2

Manhattan Bar & GrillSt. Catharines, ON

8.2

Rudders RestaurantFort Erie, ON

8.2

Ruffino's Pasta Bar & GrillNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

8.2

South Coast CookhouseFort Erie, ON

8.2

Tony's PizzeriaThorold, ON

8.2

Breakwall Brewing CompanyPort Colborne, ON

8.1

Buddy's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

8.1

Da Vinci's Pizza and WingsFort Erie, ON

8.1

Eighty 88 Eight SouthNiagara Falls, ON

8.1

Gino's PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

8.1

Julius PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

8.1

Metro BakeryNiagara Falls, ON

8.1

Mezzano's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

8.1

Papa Vince PizzeriaThorold, ON

8.1

Sonny's HideoutNiagara Falls, ON

8.1

The Old Winery Restaurant & Wine BarNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

8.1

Vaticano Italian RestaurantFort Erie, ON

8.1

Cured Tapas & CocktailsPelham, ON

8.0

On The Marc PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

8.0

Papa's PizzaFort Erie, ON

8.0

Aneta PizzeriaFort Erie, ON

7.9

Bella Noella'sSt. Catharines, ON

7.9

Bella PizzaFort Erie, ON

7.9

Boston PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

7.9

Bugsy'sSt. Catharines, ON

7.9

La Farina BakeryNiagara Falls, ON

7.9

Lina Linguini's Pasta & GrilleSt. Catharines, ON

7.9

TeatroSt. Catharines, ON

7.9

The BarrelFort Erie, ON

7.9

The Grist Craft Brewery & KitchenNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

7.9

The Pie Plate Bakery CafeNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

7.9

The Sicilian ChefFort Erie, ON

7.9

Coppola's RistoranteSt. Catharines, ON

7.8

Jo Blo's Bar & GrillSt. Catharines, ON

7.8

Maestro's PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON

7.8

Paesano Pizza (Carlton St)St. Catharines, ON

7.8

Pasta FrescaNiagara Falls, ON

7.8

Pete's Pizza (Pleasant Ave)St. Catharines, ON

7.8

Reeb HousePort Colborne, ON

7.8

Rina's PlaceFort Erie, ON

7.8

Scorecard Harry'sSt. Catharines, ON

7.8

The Rex HotelWelland, ON

7.8

Your Neighbourhood Pizza Company (McLeod Rd)Niagara Falls, ON

7.8

Fat Cat's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

7.7

Il FornelloSt. Catharines, ON

7.7

Italian Pizza and SubsNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

7.7

Merrittville Wood Fired PizzaPelham, ON

7.7

Niagara-on-the-Lake Golf ClubNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

7.7

Pizza Jerry's Union HouseSt. Catharines, ON

7.7

Alligator PearSt. Catharines, ON

7.6

Camp CataractNiagara Falls, ON

7.6

Cracker Jack's Bar & GrillThorold, ON

7.6

Pizza HutSt. Catharines, ON

7.6

Riverside TavernNiagara Falls, ON

7.6

Bro's Pizza And WingsSt. Catharines, ON

7.5

D Spot Dessert CafeSt. Catharines, ON

7.5

Mick & Angelo's Kitchen + BarNiagara Falls, ON

7.5

Nina Gelateria & Pastry ShopNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

7.5

The Pizza CompanySt. Catharines, ON

7.5

Big Brothers Gourmet PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

7.4

Caffe GattiSt. Catharines, ON

7.4

Greek on PortageNiagara Falls, ON

7.4

Hooligans Sports BarNiagara Falls, ON

7.4

Kelly GreensNiagara Falls, ON

7.4

Monty's GastropubSt. Catharines, ON

7.4

Paesano Pizza (Vine St)St. Catharines, ON

7.4

Scotty's On KingWelland, ON

7.4

Westside Pizzeria & BarSt. Catharines, ON

7.4

AJ's Pie PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON

7.3

AntipastosSt. Catharines, ON

7.3

Big Mama's & Papa's PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON

7.3

Boston PizzaWelland, ON

7.3

Butler's Bar and GrillNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

7.3

D'Vinci's PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

7.3

He's Not HereFort Erie, ON

7.3

Italia PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON

7.3

Lazy LizardSt. Catharines, ON

7.3

Owl PizzaPort Colborne, ON

7.3

Owl PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

7.3

Peppino's PizzeriaThorold, ON

7.3

Qualia PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

7.3

Zia's PizzeriaFort Erie, ON

7.3

Beach House RestaurantFort Erie, ON

7.2

Carson's Pizzeria and GastropubSt. Catharines, ON

7.2

Costco WholesaleNiagara Falls, ON

7.2

DoughBox Wood Fired Pizza & PastaSt. Catharines, ON

7.2

Masi Central PizzeriaFort Erie, ON

7.2

Nino PizzaPort Colborne, ON

7.2

PizzaBoroNiagara Falls, ON

7.2

Red Swan PizzaWelland, ON

7.2

Spicy Olive Bar and GrilleNiagara Falls, ON

7.2

Wings BlockWelland, ON

7.2

Chip N Charlie's Eatery & BarNiagara Falls, ON

7.1

Colaneri Estate WineryNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

7.1

Domino'sSt. Catharines, ON

7.1

Gino's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

7.1

Little Caesars (Drummond Rd)Niagara Falls, ON

7.1

Mulberry'sPort Colborne, ON

7.1

Pitcher's Sports Bar And GrillSt. Catharines, ON

7.1

Red Swan PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

7.1

Storky'sPort Colborne, ON

7.1

Vincent's PizzeriaWelland, ON

7.1

Portage BakeryNiagara Falls, ON

7.0

Carpaccio Restaurant & Wine BarNiagara Falls, ON

6.9

Clancy's Restaurant and BarNiagara Falls, ON

6.9

Flying J Travel CenterFort Erie, ON

6.9

Little Caesars (Fourth Ave)St. Catharines, ON

6.9

Boston PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

6.8

Casa D'PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

6.8

Cat's CabooseSt. Catharines, ON

6.8

The Plaice Bar & GrillFort Erie, ON

6.8

Tito's Pizza and WingsPort Colborne, ON

6.8

Two Sisters VineyardsNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

6.8

Your Neighbourhood Pizza Company (Portage Rd)Niagara Falls, ON

6.8

Ever Fresh PizzaWelland, ON

6.7

Four Seasons BakeryWelland, ON

6.7

PizzaioloNiagara Falls, ON

6.7

St Catharines Pizza CompanySt. Catharines, ON

6.7

Bistro Six OneNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

6.6

City South PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

6.6

Pizza HouseSt. Catharines, ON

6.6

Super 2 For 1 PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

6.5

Casa ContadinaNiagara Falls, ON

6.4

Cat's Kitchen + BarNiagara Falls, ON

6.4

Fresco's Euro GrilleSt. Catharines, ON

6.4

The BelmontPort Colborne, ON

6.4

The KavernWelland, ON

6.4

Domino'sFort Erie, ON

6.3

Flavoured Crust Pizza & WingsNiagara Falls, ON

6.3

City South PizzaWelland, ON

6.2

Gino's PizzaWelland, ON

6.2

Italia PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON

6.2

Pete's Pizza (Victoria Ave)Niagara Falls, ON

6.2

Pizza FiammaNiagara Falls, ON

6.2

Twice The Deal PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

6.2

Wingz N ThingzNiagara Falls, ON

6.2

Domino'sNiagara Falls, ON

6.1

Gambler's PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

6.1

My Cousin Vinny'sNiagara Falls, ON

6.1

Pizza HutPort Colborne, ON

6.1

Pizza PizzaWelland, ON

6.1

Twice The Deal PizzaWelland, ON

6.1

Crust N Cream Pizza & IcecreamSt. Catharines, ON

6.0

Avondale Food StoresFort Erie, ON

5.9

Domino'sWelland, ON

5.9

Domino'sNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

5.9

Moe's Tap & WingsPort Colborne, ON

5.9

Pizza HutFort Erie, ON

5.9

Quality Pizza Burgers SubsFort Erie, ON

5.9

Twice The Deal PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

5.9

Domino'sPort Colborne, ON

5.8

Noor's Subs and PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

5.8

Pizza HutWelland, ON

5.8

Pizza LoungeThorold, ON

5.8

Sandtrap Pub & GrillNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

5.8

Blind Pig NiagaraNiagara Falls, ON

5.7

Little Caesars (Glendale Ave)St. Catharines, ON

5.7

Mama Mia's Italian EateryNiagara Falls, ON

5.7

Old Bank BistroFort Erie, ON

5.7

Stromboli's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

5.7

Trappers Sports BarWelland, ON

5.7

Sneaker's Beach TavernFort Erie, ON

5.6

CC's Dugout Italian EateryWelland, ON

5.5

Popular PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

5.5

Metro LakeshoreSt. Catharines, ON

5.2

Pizza Party All NightNiagara Falls, ON

5.2

Pizza PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

5.2

Score PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

5.2

Papa John'sSt. Catharines, ON

5.1

Score PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

5.1

Pizza DepotNiagara Falls, ON

5.0

PZA MIANiagara Falls, ON

4.9

Little Caesars (Lundy's Ln)Niagara Falls, ON

4.7

The Overtime PubThorold, ON

4.7

Pizza PizzaFort Erie, ON

4.5

Papa John'sNiagara Falls, ON

4.4

Qualia PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

4.4

Strada WestNiagara Falls, ON

4.4

Red Swan PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

4.3

7-ElevenPort Colborne, ON

4.2

Wild WingSt. Catharines, ON

4.2

Wrigley's Sports Bar & LoungeSt. Catharines, ON

4.1

Commisso's Fresh FoodsNiagara Falls, ON

3.9

Jumbo's PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

3.9

Little CaesarsFort Erie, ON

3.9

Little CaesarsPort Colborne, ON

3.6

7-ElevenSt. Catharines, ON

3.4

Wayne Gretzky EstatesNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

3.3

Pizza PizzaNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON

Niagara-on-the-Lake

2.6

Little CaesarsWelland, ON

2.5

Pizza PizzaSt. Catharines, ON

2.3

Everyday PizzaNiagara Falls, ON

2.1

No pizzerias match that search yet. Try another town or name.

How the list works

One judge. One scale.

Every pizzeria on this list was visited by Pizza Review Joe and scored on camera. The same person scores every pie, so an 8.6 in Welland means the same thing as an 8.6 in Niagara Falls.

Prices are what Joe paid on the day of his visit, in Canadian dollars, so they’re a guide, not a menu. Scores and rankings update as new reviews go up.

Jump to a town

St. Catharines80 Niagara Falls75 Welland31 Fort Erie27 Niagara-on-the-Lake21 Port Colborne17 Thorold8

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria