Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Home/Rankings/Best Pizza in North Niagara
Joe’s Short List

Best of North Niagara

The best pizza along the Lake Ontario side of the region: St. Catharines, Niagara-on-the-Lake and Thorold, ranked together.

109Pizzerias
9.3Top score
$18.47Average price
Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
Niagara Oast House BrewersNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$32.70
9.3
02
oddBarSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$22.60
9.1
03
Boss PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$31.00
9.1
04
Di's Pizza PiesSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$32.76
9.1
05
Volcano PizzeriaThorold, ON
Thorold
$18.07
9.1
06
BrocatoeatzSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$25.00
9.0
07
Johnny Rocco's Italian GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$17.52
9.0
08
Pie Guys Tap And GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$20.62
9.0
09
Bricks & BarleyNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$15.82
8.9
10
Cafe AmoreSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.36
8.9
11
Pete's Pizza (Bunting Rd)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$19.76
8.9
12
Garage PizzaNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$22.60
8.8
13
Fat Louie's American Style Pizzeria & BarSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.07
8.7
14
Golden GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$41.70
8.6
15
Johnny Rocco's Pizza WagonThorold, ON
Thorold
$10.00
8.6
16
Olee's Ale HouseSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$15.82
8.6
17
The Twisted PigSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$21.47
8.6
18
Fat Louie's Pizzeria & BarSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$19.20
8.5
19
Pete's Pizza (Lakeshore Rd)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$19.20
8.5
20
Petrullo MarketplaceNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$17.50
8.4
21
Pie Guys Pizzeria (Linwell Rd)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$20.62
8.4
22
Restaurant 88St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$17.94
8.4
23
Rollin' PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$25.43
8.4
24
13th Street WinerySt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.08
8.3
25
Big Marco's Italian RestaurantSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$17.00
8.3
26
Fabio's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$17.52
8.3
27
Kully's Original Sports BarSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$33.89
8.3
28
Pieza Pizza & VinoNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$22.60
8.3
29
Ravine Vineyard Estate WineryNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$28.25
8.3
30
Manhattan Bar & GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.05
8.2
31
Ruffino's Pasta Bar & GrillNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$23.73
8.2
32
Tony's PizzeriaThorold, ON
Thorold
$17.80
8.2
33
Buddy's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
8.1
34
Julius PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.10
8.1
35
Mezzano's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.70
8.1
36
Papa Vince PizzeriaThorold, ON
Thorold
$18.07
8.1
37
The Old Winery Restaurant & Wine BarNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$15.82
8.1
38
On The Marc PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.45
8.0
39
Bella Noella'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$20.34
7.9
40
Bugsy'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$17.75
7.9
41
Lina Linguini's Pasta & GrilleSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.07
7.9
42
TeatroSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$29.38
7.9
43
The Grist Craft Brewery & KitchenNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$16.95
7.9
44
The Pie Plate Bakery CafeNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$8.98
7.9
45
Coppola's RistoranteSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$20.34
7.8
46
Jo Blo's Bar & GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$20.84
7.8
47
Maestro's PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
7.8
48
Paesano Pizza (Carlton St)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$13.00
7.8
49
Pete's Pizza (Pleasant Ave)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
—
7.8
50
Scorecard Harry'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$27.63
7.8
51
Fat Cat's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.33
7.7
52
Il FornelloSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.65
7.7
53
Italian Pizza and SubsNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$12.71
7.7
54
Niagara-on-the-Lake Golf ClubNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$16.95
7.7
55
Pizza Jerry's Union HouseSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
—
7.7
56
Alligator PearSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$20.34
7.6
57
Cracker Jack's Bar & GrillThorold, ON
Thorold
$20.91
7.6
58
Pizza HutSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$25.13
7.6
59
Bro's Pizza And WingsSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.30
7.5
60
D Spot Dessert CafeSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$23.73
7.5
61
Nina Gelateria & Pastry ShopNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$14.70
7.5
62
The Pizza CompanySt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.39
7.5
63
Big Brothers Gourmet PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
7.4
64
Caffe GattiSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$33.90
7.4
65
Monty's GastropubSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$15.82
7.4
66
Paesano Pizza (Vine St)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$13.95
7.4
67
Westside Pizzeria & BarSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$21.98
7.4
68
AJ's Pie PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.35
7.3
69
AntipastosSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$20.88
7.3
70
Big Mama's & Papa's PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.70
7.3
71
Butler's Bar and GrillNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$15.82
7.3
72
Lazy LizardSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.06
7.3
73
Owl PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
7.3
74
Peppino's PizzeriaThorold, ON
Thorold
$16.90
7.3
75
Carson's Pizzeria and GastropubSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$28.24
7.2
76
DoughBox Wood Fired Pizza & PastaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.94
7.2
77
Colaneri Estate WineryNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$18.00
7.1
78
Domino'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.11
7.1
79
Gino's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.42
7.1
80
Pitcher's Sports Bar And GrillSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.00
7.1
81
Little Caesars (Fourth Ave)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$10.16
6.9
82
Boston PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$27.96
6.8
83
Cat's CabooseSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$22.58
6.8
84
Two Sisters VineyardsNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$24.86
6.8
85
St Catharines Pizza CompanySt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.53
6.7
86
Bistro Six OneNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$16.94
6.6
87
Pizza HouseSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.84
6.6
88
Super 2 For 1 PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$9.05
6.5
89
Fresco's Euro GrilleSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$18.07
6.4
90
Italia PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.29
6.2
91
Twice The Deal PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$9.05
6.2
92
Crust N Cream Pizza & IcecreamSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.40
6.0
93
Domino'sNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$14.68
5.9
94
Pizza LoungeThorold, ON
Thorold
$12.42
5.8
95
Sandtrap Pub & GrillNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$21.35
5.8
96
Little Caesars (Glendale Ave)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.29
5.7
97
Stromboli's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.61
5.7
98
Metro LakeshoreSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.42
5.2
99
Score PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.87
5.2
100
Papa John'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
5.1
101
The Overtime PubThorold, ON
Thorold
$16.33
4.7
102
Qualia PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$13.55
4.4
103
Red Swan PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$21.41
4.3
104
Wild WingSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$10.86
4.2
105
Wrigley's Sports Bar & LoungeSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$16.94
4.1
106
7-ElevenSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.98
3.4
107
Wayne Gretzky EstatesNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$24.86
3.3
108
Pizza PizzaNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$16.60
2.6
109
Pizza PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$10.72
2.3
On Camera

Watch the top picks

St. Catharines, Niagara-on-the-Lake and Thorold, on camera.

Niagara Oast House Brewers pizza review
9.3

Niagara Oast House Brewers

Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON · $32.70
oddBar pizza review
9.1

oddBar

St. Catharines, ON · $22.60
Boss Pizza pizza review
9.1

Boss Pizza

St. Catharines, ON · $31.00
Di's Pizza Pies pizza review
9.1

Di's Pizza Pies

St. Catharines, ON · $32.76

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria