Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Home/Towns/Port Colborne
Port Colborne, Ontario

Best pizza in Port Colborne, ON

This is where Joe’s Niagara pizza quest kicked off back in 2020. Port Colborne packs a lot of good pizza into a small canal town, and a couple of spots on Main Street and Clarence Street have become fan favourites.

17Pizzerias ranked
8.9Top score
$15.06Average price
#1 in Port Colborne

The best pizza in Port Colborne

The Spot pizza review
#1 in Port Colborne
8.9SCORE

The Spot

Price $15.26Overall rank #23 of 261

The top-scoring pizza Joe has found in Port Colborne. Watch the full review and see why it beat the rest.

Watch the review
The Ranking

Every pizzeria in Port Colborne

Joe has ranked 17 pizzerias in Port Colborne. Here’s how they stack up.

Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
The SpotPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$15.26
8.9
02
The Lock Wood Fired PizzaPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$12.00
8.7
03
Super Mario'sPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
—
8.5
04
Whisky Run Golf ClubPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$22.54
8.4
05
Breakwall Brewing CompanyPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$17.52
8.1
06
Reeb HousePort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$16.94
7.8
07
Owl PizzaPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$14.68
7.3
08
Nino PizzaPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$12.40
7.2
09
Mulberry'sPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$11.29
7.1
10
Storky'sPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$10.99
7.1
11
Tito's Pizza and WingsPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$14.49
6.8
12
The BelmontPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$14.97
6.4
13
Pizza HutPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$20.33
6.1
14
Moe's Tap & WingsPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
—
5.9
15
Domino'sPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
—
5.8
16
7-ElevenPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$10.50
4.2
17
Little CaesarsPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$16.95
3.6

Nearby towns

Best pizza in St. Catharines80Best pizza in Niagara Falls75Best pizza in Welland31Best pizza in Fort Erie27Best pizza in Niagara-on-the-Lake21Best pizza in Thorold8

Short lists

Full Niagara rankings261Best under $1583Best of North Niagara109Best of South Niagara77
On Camera

Watch every Port Colborne review

All reviews
The Spot pizza review8.9
Port Colborne, ON · #23 of 261

The Spot

$15.26 · Cheese pepperoni with cup and char
225 Main St W, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3V7
DirectionsYouTube
The Lock Wood Fired Pizza pizza review8.7
Port Colborne, ON · #31 of 261

The Lock Wood Fired Pizza

$12.00 · Regular cheese pepperoni
11 Clarence St, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3E7
DirectionsYouTube
Super Mario's pizza review8.5
Port Colborne, ON · #44 of 261

Super Mario's

Large cheese pepperoni
281 King St, Port Colborne, ON L3K 4H2
DirectionsYouTube
Whisky Run Golf Club pizza review8.4
Port Colborne, ON · #57 of 261

Whisky Run Golf Club

$22.54 · Detroit-style pepperoni with cup and char
631 Lorraine Rd, Port Colborne, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Breakwall Brewing Company pizza review8.1
Port Colborne, ON · #75 of 261

Breakwall Brewing Company

$17.52 · Cheese pepperoni with cup and char (one size)
46 Clarence St, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3E9
DirectionsYouTube
Reeb House pizza review7.8
Port Colborne, ON · #108 of 261

Reeb House

$16.94 · Large thin crust cheese pepperoni
2481 ON-3, Port Colborne, ON L3K 5V3
DirectionsYouTube
Owl Pizza pizza review7.3
Port Colborne, ON · #147 of 261

Owl Pizza

$14.68 · Large 14-inch cheese pepperoni
398 Main St W, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3W1
DirectionsYouTube
Nino Pizza pizza review7.2
Port Colborne, ON · #157 of 261

Nino Pizza

$12.40 · Large cheese pepperoni
474 Main St W, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3W1
DirectionsYouTube
Mulberry's pizza review7.1
Port Colborne, ON · #167 of 261

Mulberry's

$11.29 · Large cheese pepperoni
26 Clarence St, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3E8
DirectionsYouTube
Storky's pizza review7.1
Port Colborne, ON · #170 of 261

Storky's

$10.99 · Large cheese pepperoni
DirectionsYouTube
Tito's Pizza and Wings pizza review6.8
Port Colborne, ON · #181 of 261

Tito's Pizza and Wings

$14.49 · Large 14-inch cheese pepperoni
DirectionsYouTube
The Belmont pizza review6.4
Port Colborne, ON · #195 of 261

The Belmont

$14.97 · Large cheese pepperoni
175 King St, Port Colborne, ON L3K 4G5
DirectionsYouTube
Pizza Hut pizza review6.1
Port Colborne, ON · #209 of 261

Pizza Hut

$20.33 · Large cheese pepperoni
111 Clarence St Unit D, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3G2
DirectionsYouTube
Moe's Tap & Wings pizza review5.9
Port Colborne, ON · #216 of 261

Moe's Tap & Wings

Cheese pepperoni
190 Main St E, Port Colborne, ON
DirectionsYouTube
Domino's pizza review5.8
Port Colborne, ON · #220 of 261

Domino's

Cheese pepperoni
DirectionsYouTube
7-Eleven pizza review4.2
Port Colborne, ON · #249 of 261

7-Eleven

$10.50 · Cheese pepperoni
111 Clarence St W, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3G2
DirectionsYouTube
Little Caesars pizza review3.6
Port Colborne, ON · #255 of 261

Little Caesars

$16.95 · Large cheese pepperoni
287 West Side Rd, Port Colborne, ON L3K 5L2
DirectionsYouTube
Christopher's Pizza pizza review—
Port Colborne, ON

Christopher's Pizza

$15.70 · Large cheese pepperoni
94 Killaly St W, Port Colborne, ON L3K 3L6
DirectionsYouTube

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria