Rankings Towns Reviews About Joe Recommend a Spot Full Rankings
Home/Rankings/Best Cheap Pizza in Niagara
Joe’s Short List

Best pizza in Niagara under $15

Great pizza doesn’t have to cost a fortune. These are the top-scoring pies Joe paid less than $15 for, ranked by score.

83Pizzerias
9.2Top score
$12.39Average price
Rank
Pizzeria
Town
Price
Joe’s Score
01
The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports BarNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$13.50
9.2
02
Volcano PizzeriaWelland, ON
Welland
$13.50
8.8
03
The Lock Wood Fired PizzaPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$12.00
8.7
04
Johnny Rocco's Pizza WagonThorold, ON
Thorold
$10.00
8.6
05
San Vito's Italian Bistro & BarFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.56
8.6
06
The Brick Oven Pizza CompanyWelland, ON
Welland
$13.00
8.5
07
Buddy's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
8.1
08
Gino's PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.29
8.1
09
Mezzano's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.70
8.1
10
On The Marc PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.45
8.0
11
Papa's PizzaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$14.65
8.0
12
The Pie Plate Bakery CafeNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$8.98
7.9
13
Maestro's PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
7.8
14
Paesano Pizza (Carlton St)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$13.00
7.8
15
Your Neighbourhood Pizza Company (McLeod Rd)Niagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$13.50
7.8
16
Italian Pizza and SubsNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$12.71
7.7
17
Bro's Pizza And WingsSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.30
7.5
18
Nina Gelateria & Pastry ShopNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$14.70
7.5
19
Big Brothers Gourmet PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
7.4
20
Paesano Pizza (Vine St)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$13.95
7.4
21
Big Mama's & Papa's PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.70
7.3
22
Italia PizzeriaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.29
7.3
23
Owl PizzaPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$14.68
7.3
24
Owl PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
7.3
25
Qualia PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.30
7.3
26
Zia's PizzeriaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.84
7.3
27
Beach House RestaurantFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.00
7.2
28
Costco WholesaleNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$14.68
7.2
29
Masi Central PizzeriaFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.55
7.2
30
Nino PizzaPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$12.40
7.2
31
Red Swan PizzaWelland, ON
Welland
$13.50
7.2
32
Domino'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.11
7.1
33
Gino's PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.42
7.1
34
Mulberry'sPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$11.29
7.1
35
Red Swan PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$12.35
7.1
36
Storky'sPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$10.99
7.1
37
Little Caesars (Fourth Ave)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$10.16
6.9
38
Tito's Pizza and WingsPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$14.49
6.8
39
Your Neighbourhood Pizza Company (Portage Rd)Niagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$13.00
6.8
40
Ever Fresh PizzaWelland, ON
Welland
$13.55
6.7
41
St Catharines Pizza CompanySt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.53
6.7
42
City South PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$12.42
6.6
43
Super 2 For 1 PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$9.05
6.5
44
The BelmontPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$14.97
6.4
45
Domino'sFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$10.16
6.3
46
Flavoured Crust Pizza & WingsNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$14.68
6.3
47
City South PizzaWelland, ON
Welland
$13.84
6.2
48
Gino's PizzaWelland, ON
Welland
$13.56
6.2
49
Italia PizzeriaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.29
6.2
50
Pete's Pizza (Victoria Ave)Niagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.30
6.2
51
Pizza FiammaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$14.68
6.2
52
Twice The Deal PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$9.05
6.2
53
Domino'sNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.29
6.1
54
Gambler's PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$14.70
6.1
55
Twice The Deal PizzaWelland, ON
Welland
$10.16
6.1
56
Crust N Cream Pizza & IcecreamSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.40
6.0
57
Avondale Food StoresFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$14.85
5.9
58
Domino'sNiagara-on-the-Lake, ON
Niagara-on-the-Lake
$14.68
5.9
59
Pizza HutFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$9.05
5.9
60
Quality Pizza Burgers SubsFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$14.68
5.9
61
Twice The Deal PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$7.90
5.9
62
Noor's Subs and PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$12.00
5.8
63
Pizza HutWelland, ON
Welland
$2.00
5.8
64
Pizza LoungeThorold, ON
Thorold
$12.42
5.8
65
Little Caesars (Glendale Ave)St. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.29
5.7
66
Sneaker's Beach TavernFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$13.15
5.6
67
CC's Dugout Italian EateryWelland, ON
Welland
$5.00
5.5
68
Metro LakeshoreSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.42
5.2
69
Pizza Party All NightNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$13.83
5.2
70
Pizza PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$10.16
5.2
71
Score PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$11.87
5.2
72
Papa John'sSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$14.68
5.1
73
PZA MIANiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$12.42
4.9
74
Little Caesars (Lundy's Ln)Niagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$14.68
4.7
75
Qualia PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$13.55
4.4
76
7-ElevenPort Colborne, ON
Port Colborne
$10.50
4.2
77
Wild WingSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$10.86
4.2
78
Jumbo's PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.50
3.9
79
Little CaesarsFort Erie, ON
Fort Erie
$6.77
3.9
80
7-ElevenSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$12.98
3.4
81
Little CaesarsWelland, ON
Welland
$14.68
2.5
82
Pizza PizzaSt. Catharines, ON
St. Catharines
$10.72
2.3
83
Everyday PizzaNiagara Falls, ON
Niagara Falls
$11.00
2.1
On Camera

Watch the top picks

Prices are what Joe paid at the time of his visit.

The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports Bar pizza review
9.2

The Eager Beaver Eatery and Sports Bar

Niagara Falls, ON · $13.50
Volcano Pizzeria pizza review
8.8

Volcano Pizzeria

Welland, ON · $13.50
The Lock Wood Fired Pizza pizza review
8.7

The Lock Wood Fired Pizza

Port Colborne, ON · $12.00
Johnny Rocco's Pizza Wagon pizza review
8.6

Johnny Rocco's Pizza Wagon

Thorold, ON · $10.00

Know a spot Joe missed?

Send it in. The best tips become the next review on the channel.

Recommend a Pizzeria